SoHo Slice Pizzeria

We thought we would give this restaurant a try and ordered a takeout large Puttanesca pizza. I was there to pick up the pizza in a timely manner having to wait a few minutes before it came out. I should have been suspicious at the start as the bottom of the box was damp. So much so that I hurried home (1.8 miles) to make sure the box didn’t break through. When I got home the pizza was so wet and doughy that I had to reheat it on a pizza stone. I couldn’t get it out of the box as it came apart and I had to use a cutting board to transfer it into the oven. What a mess! There were hunks of stewed tomatoes and 1/2 artichoke hearts that were really wet, and when I got a couple of slices out of the box, I was able to get a photo of the bottom of the box. The knife cuts are visible and the box is falling apart. Needless to say, with all these other pizza places available, we won’t be ordering from here again. And I left a tip, what was I thinking?

Sorry- I ate my pizza before I could take a photo.. but I have to say, I was pleasantly impressed with SOHO pizza. I sat at the bar since I was alone and ordered a small pie- half pepperoni.. Wow, it was pretty damn good. Not overly burnt (like some brick oven) and lots of tasty pepperoni. The bartender rendered excellent service and a really good Cosmo. So, I am from NY -this does not make me a pizza expert- other than I have eaten A-LOT of great pizza and some awful
Ones also in NY - just thought I would throw that out there. At SOHO the pizza was EXCELLENT! I thought the price (reasonable) for the quality was pretty fair. Definitely returning with my hubby and friends! I can see a busy Summer for them👍

So glad that Atlantic Social is gone and SoHo Slice has arrived. The bar service is about the same as it was at AC, even the bartenders are the same. But the food! WOW! Great pizza! We sat at the bar and talked to several other customers. Everyone, including us, had high praise of the new menu and kitchen. You can tell by the crowds that they are doing it right. We will be back soon.