Miltonian Pizzeria & Wing House

SHAFTED.

I ordered extra celery, they charged me for it, I which i was goof with until I saw how little they gave me. Cool, I’m stupid and I’ll never do that again because I’ll never eat here again. It’s gross to do shit like that to your customers in this economy. I tipped 15% on a pickup order too, which I always do. It’s the principal for me. Can’t believe I got shafted on celery.

What a fantastic pizzeria! We’ve lived here for a year and somehow just discovered this gem—better late than never, right? The staff was a highlight too, with our waitress/staff being super friendly and attentive, like she had a sixth sense for when we needed more napkins or a refill (no mind-reading required, apparently!). We absolutely loved the pizza, with its super-fresh pepperoni that puts the competition to shame. They went a bit overboard on the black olives (think olive avalanche), which was heaven for me but sparked a friendly debate with my partner. Luckily, the generous heap of pepperoni had us both high-fiving in agreement. We also tackled the “Killer” wings, which turned out to be more “Kitten” level—barely a tingle, but hey, who needs fire-breathing when the flavor’s on point? We’ll most definitely be back; that endless trek to Lewes/Rehoboth was starting to feel like a bad road trip movie. Oh, and we snagged some cannolis for dessert—pure bliss awaits!

Great pizza. Amazing service. Beautiful dining room. Too many good things to say from their unique wing sauces, the best homemade salad dressing, and pepperoni that curls up in the oven. Oh, and that cheese pull!!!